Post by rawkkinggoodguy on Oct 8, 2009 12:30:08 GMT -5
Hmm, I just realized making a move by me will likely implicate fatal if I do so.
This was the post I was thinking of making:
There was an attempt at an Ardor bandwagon yesterday, and Dogbone voted for him again today (I think he also voted for him yesterday). I think it's incredibly unlikely that Ardor is mafia, and these votes are suspicious and should be looked at. Think about it: if Ardor was mafia, then he would only make such a vote analysis post if all the mafia were able and willing to quickly jump onto the day 1 SkyCaptain bandwagon. This is a terrible idea for any mafia group to do, as you would essentially be starting a new game villager:mafia ratio skewed in the village's favor, with only the slight advantage of being able to point fingers at the innocent villagers that didn't vote for the mafia.
Basically a time bomb based on selective reason that potentially gets Dogbone voted out and implicates Ardor when a mafia member dies. Though the implication only really works if I do it.
Ringo wrote: Now I don't know the disposition of either of you, but what I do know is that you're both in the same room as Oaklore. The few posts Oaklore has made have contained a lot of words that didn't say a lot and also had some bad assumptions/misleading information in them. In my short experience with Oaklore that is not his usual style, and in talking with a few other people they've pointed out that the last time he was doing something similar he turned out to be mafia in the Bioshock Phalla.
So why am I sending you this? Because I have a feeling there will be more tempting vote targets today than Oaklore. But one, or both of you could attack him tonight.
Of course, that's all moot if you know something I don't, or don't believe Oaklore to be a Bodyguard. But I thought I'd just throw this out there and see if either of you were feeling the same way.
Hmm, thanks for the heads up I guess. I dunno, it's not much to go on. Edcrab, thoughts?
I guess it's something, and I was just thinking that similar logic correctly identified Kay, but I'm not sure it's worth killing him over.
Unless you guys really, really don't like him!
I have nothing against oaklore. He does seem to be making a lot of reading comp fails lately though.
I only have one attack card in my hand though, and I'd kind of rather save it up for a bit.
I think that cinches it then, I don't particularly want to blow mine either. We may regret it, but I say we leave him be for now!